Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Kansas Students Walk Out on Online, Personalized Learning
#1
Due to budget cuts, schools in Kansas started using a web-based platform and curriculum called Summit Learning. Students work at their own pace on a Chromebook; the curriculum is personalized to each student. It sounds a lot like competency-based learning, especially the personalized learning programs at Northern Arizona University. I've said many times that research has found that young people perform worse in online classes than they do in face-to-face classes. So, it's no surprise that students had such a negative reaction to a competency-based program, which is probably even worse than being in a traditional, online class. 

Not only did students at Wellington High School in Kansas walk out, but there have been walkouts and protests in other states over Summit Learning. Some parents have even pulled their children out of public schools. Some students have been complaining of eyestrain and feeling isolated. 

Quote:Then, students started coming home with headaches and hand cramps. Some said they felt more anxious. One child began having a recurrence of seizures. Another asked to bring her dad’s hunting earmuffs to class to block out classmates because work was now done largely alone.

https://www.nytimes.com/2019/04/21/techn...hools.html
Graduate of Not VUL or ENEB
MS, MSS and Graduate Cert
AAS, AS, BA, and BS
CLEP
Intro Psych 70, US His I 64, Intro Soc 63, Intro Edu Psych 70, A&I Lit 64, Bio 68, Prin Man 69, Prin Mar 68
DSST
Life Dev Psych 62, Fund Coun 68, Intro Comp 469, Intro Astr 56, Env & Hum 70, HTYH 456, MIS 451, Prin Sup 453, HRM 62, Bus Eth 458
ALEKS
Int Alg, Coll Alg
TEEX
4 credits
TECEP
Fed Inc Tax, Sci of Nutr, Micro, Strat Man, Med Term, Pub Relations
CSU
Sys Analysis & Design, Programming, Cyber
SL
Intro to Comm, Microbio, Acc I
Uexcel
A&P
Davar
Macro, Intro to Fin, Man Acc
Reply
#2
such a nightmare. I feel really really awful for students who won't feel empowered by their education but instead feel trapped by it.

I am highly bothered by this quote
“Change rarely comes without some bumps in the road,” said Gordon Mohn, McPherson’s superintendent of schools. He added, “Students are becoming self-directed learners and are demonstrating greater ownership of their learning activities.”

Self-direction. Self. Self. Let's define "self" - and then define "directed" and this program is the opposite of what *actual* self-directed learning is! Ownership? They walked out. That's owning it!
Reply
#3
I'm not familiar with the summit software, but I feel that SOME well designed software COULD be implemented as a supplement in certain circumstances.

I don't think it should completely replace conventional learning for every student though.
WGU BSIT Complete January 2022
(77CU transferred in)(44/44CU ) 

RA(non WGU)(57cr)
JST/TESU Eval of NAVY Training(85/99cr)
The Institutes, TEEX, NFA(9cr): Ethics, Cyber 101/201/301, Safety
Sophia(60cr): 23 classes
Study.com(31cr): Eng105, Fin102, His108, LibSci101, Math104, Stat101, CS107, CS303, BUS107
CLEP(9cr): Intro Sociology 63 Intro Psych 61 US GOV 71
OD(12cr): Robotics, Cyber, Programming, Microecon
CSM(3cr)
Various IT/Cybersecurity Certifications from: CompTIA, Google, Microsoft, AWS, GIAC, LPI, IBM
CS Fund. MicroBachelor(3cr)
Reply
#4
My kids are both in high school, and go to different high schools (various reasons). They both have online math courses that they do in school. My daughter because it's the only option for her program; my son because he had a horrible teacher and asked to switch. They both HATE it. Different circumstances, different kids, different schools, both are on-campus - and both really, really hate the format, and the isolation (even my kid who basically homeschools herself for her other courses). It's just not a good format for a lot of kids.

One of the things they both hate is the pace - it's "self-paced" but really drags. The videos are slower than they'd like, and are fairly long (maybe 7-10 minutes), and it just really annoys both of them. If it was a little more "fun" they might like it better I think.

I do like the idea of the "backwards" ALEKS model that I heard about - where kids all go at their own pace, and watch the videos and try to do the problems at home, and then the next day they come in and the teacher helps them if they had any problems. Class time is NOT spent on the computer, which is more like a regular class. Not sure how well it works and how well the kids do though.
TESU BSBA/HR 2018 - WVNCC BOG AAS 2017 - GGU Cert in Mgmt 2000
EXAMS: TECEP Tech Wrtg, Comp II, LA Math, PR, Computers  DSST Computers, Pers Fin  CLEP Mgmt, Mktg
COURSES: TESU Capstone  Study.com Pers Fin, Microecon, Stats  Ed4Credit Acct 2  PF Fin Mgmt  ALEKS Int & Coll Alg  Sophia Proj Mgmt The Institutes - Ins Ethics  Kaplan PLA
Reply
#5
I've always thought that computers in the classroom should mainly be used to teach about computers, not used to replace teachers. It's fine for an adult, or even the occasional teen, to CHOOSE to take online courses, but to hand a bunch of the day to day teaching off to an online platform is reckless.
NanoDegree: Intro to Self-Driving Cars (2019)
Coursera: Stanford Machine Learning (2019)
TESU: BA in Comp Sci (2016)
TECEP:Env Ethics (2015); TESU PLA:Software Eng, Computer Arch, C++, Advanced C++, Data Struct (2015); TESU Courses:Capstone, Database Mngmnt Sys, Op Sys, Artificial Intel, Discrete Math, Intro to Portfolio Dev, Intro PLA (2014-16); DSST:Anthro, Pers Fin, Astronomy (2014); CLEP:Intro to Soc (2014); Saylor.org:Intro to Computers (2014); CC: 69 units (1980-88)

PLA Tips Thread - TESU: What is in a Portfolio?
[-] The following 1 user Likes davewill's post:
  • Muldoon
Reply
#6
I've worked a bit with Plato/Edmentum software(which is typically geared towards k-12). If it's anything at all like the summit learning platform, then it's outright horrible and probably worthless. I've also worked with other platforms that are highly interactive and engaging and wonderfully put together like school yourself. I think high quality, customizable, interactive software could be a valuable tool in the future of education as a SUPPLEMENT. But in my observations, the students usually get stuck with poor quality implementations that were developed on a low budget.
WGU BSIT Complete January 2022
(77CU transferred in)(44/44CU ) 

RA(non WGU)(57cr)
JST/TESU Eval of NAVY Training(85/99cr)
The Institutes, TEEX, NFA(9cr): Ethics, Cyber 101/201/301, Safety
Sophia(60cr): 23 classes
Study.com(31cr): Eng105, Fin102, His108, LibSci101, Math104, Stat101, CS107, CS303, BUS107
CLEP(9cr): Intro Sociology 63 Intro Psych 61 US GOV 71
OD(12cr): Robotics, Cyber, Programming, Microecon
CSM(3cr)
Various IT/Cybersecurity Certifications from: CompTIA, Google, Microsoft, AWS, GIAC, LPI, IBM
CS Fund. MicroBachelor(3cr)
Reply
#7
(04-22-2019, 05:45 PM)sanantone Wrote: Some students have been complaining of eyestrain and feeling isolated. 

That's because they haven't read my postSmile Tongue
[-] The following 1 user Likes pws's post:
  • ROYISAGIRL
Reply
#8
I visited a charter school that used competency based learning, about 30 kids and 30 computers with one teacher managing from a 'control' desk, and it was AMAZING. They would use the charter school to separate problem kids from the nearby public school and also the really smart kids that didn't learn anything. A lot of kids would go in and work really hard for three hours and be finished for the day.

I was tasked with placing an international student at a school and two of three were really too dangerous (according to reputation). For kids that were having trouble, there was a teacher to help.

I would imagine this is more an issue of roll out. Or maybe the kids are used to bird courses like P.E.
OnlineDegree
Intro to Marketing and Strategy ($9) | Intro to Microeconomics ($9)

Study
Intro to Managerial Accounting ($70) | Advanced Accounting ($70) | Managerial Accounting ($80) | Intermediate Accounting 2 ($90) | Intermediate Accounting I ($90) | Cybersecurity Policies & Management ($80) | Management Information Systems ($80) | Data Structures & Algorithms ($80) | Intro to Programming ($70) | Computer Architecture ($70) | Calculus ($80) Database Management ($80)
Systems Analysis & Design ($70) | Discrete Math ($80) | Intro to Operation Systems ($80)

Saylor.org
Intro to Computer Science I ($25)
Reply


Possibly Related Threads...
Thread Author Replies Views Last Post
Question How can I Study on my own pace and online like a european? justmemyself 6 280 03-25-2024, 09:14 PM
Last Post: bjcheung77
  Biochemistry online, no lab, and less than $500. GoodYellowDogs 11 10,153 03-20-2024, 04:16 PM
Last Post: bjcheung77
  The 100 Most Popular Accredited Online Colleges for 2024 LevelUP 2 215 03-20-2024, 05:47 AM
Last Post: nyvrem
  Online Ivy League degree programs that require less than a week on campus sanantone 27 5,463 03-16-2024, 06:22 AM
Last Post: bjcheung77
Lightbulb ASU to Launch a Free Global Initiative and enroll 100 million students MNomadic 203 28,720 03-11-2024, 10:55 AM
Last Post: bjcheung77
  Eastern University Self-Paced online Degrees natshar 2 605 03-06-2024, 10:03 PM
Last Post: jumlouh
  University of California System Bans Fully Online Degrees davewill 23 3,618 03-01-2024, 10:57 AM
Last Post: NotJoeBiden
  LLB University of London Online newdegree 1 353 02-28-2024, 01:46 PM
Last Post: freeloader
  Is online college easier now? Vle045 21 1,092 02-26-2024, 10:47 PM
Last Post: Vle045
  Free or affordable Christian Chaplaincy Online Sowak777 4 370 02-21-2024, 06:39 AM
Last Post: The need 2 learn

Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)